While there’s no universally guaranteed “most effective” bait for squirrel traps, some attractants tend to be quite successful based on squirrels’ natural foraging habits. Here are some top options to consider:
- Peanut Butter: A classic choice for a reason, squirrels love peanut butter. Use a glob in the back of the trap,securing it with a dab of glue or string to prevent them from taking it without triggering the trap. Opt for crunchy peanut butter if available, as chunky varieties can be more difficult to remove and provide more enticement.
- Nuts in the Shell: Pecans, walnuts, and hickory nuts are all natural favorites for squirrels. Place a whole nut in the back of the trap or even crack it slightly to expose the inside a bit. This will trigger their instinct to gnaw and get them moving further into the trap.
- Seeds: Sunflower seeds, pumpkin seeds, and even a mix of birdseed can be effective bait, especially for younger squirrels. Scatter a few seeds leading up to the trap entrance and some inside the back to entice them in.
Here are some additional tips for maximizing bait effectiveness:
- Freshness is Key: Use fresh bait for each trap setting. Old or spoiled nuts or peanut butter will be less appealing to squirrels.
- Variety can Help: Experiment with different baits to see what works best in your particular situation. Squirrels can develop a preference for one type of bait over another, so rotating options can keep them curious.
- Consider Seasonality: Squirrels may adjust their feeding habits depending on the season. In the winter, they might be more drawn to high-fat options like peanut butter, while in the summer, they might prefer nuts or seeds.
- Combine Baits: You can sometimes improve your chances by using a combination of baits. For example, smear some peanut butter on a pecan or hickory nut to create a double dose of temptation.
Remember, even with the most enticing bait, it may take some trial and error to find what works best for the squirrels in your area. Be patient, keep your traps clean and free of human scent, and you should eventually have success.
